So I've been thinking lately about fandom and how it develops and the effects of new people becoming part of fandoms and the evolution of fic. I've been the wide-eyed new person in a fandom, and I've been the old timer yelling for those damn kids to get off the lawn, so I've seen it a bit from both sides and I find it all very interesting. I have a few thoughts/questions, for those in the mood to humor me.
So when you first discover a new fandom and start thinking about the first fic you're going to write, what kind of fic is it? My experience is ALWAYS THE SAME. I start imagining this epic
angsty getting-together fic for whichever pairing I have deemed my OTP, start planning it in my head, then start reading pre-existing fics and realize that I've pretty much hit every cliche right on the head. :| And realize that my plotline is the most common and overused plotline in the fandom. :| And that I always ship the obvious pairings. :| I am so uncreative. But I am running into this problem as a PoT newbie, when my "OMG I HAVE TO WRITE EPIC TEZUKA/RYOMA FIC RIGHT NOW" plot bunny cowered in the corner after I read some of the pairing classics.
But all of this got me thinking, because I've been on the other side of the fence where I'm thinking, "OMFG, if I see one more Monday fic I'm going to rip my hair out. Why do all new people have to write the same damn story? Can't they see that it's already been written a
thousand times?!" But of course that was the first thing I wrote when I entered the TBC fandom, so basically I am a hypocrite. :p
Anyway, my larger point/question: I think when you first enter a fandom as a writer/reader, you have to start at the beginning. Reading established!pairing fics right off the bat is probably not the best way to be introduced to a non-canon pairing, because we need to see and understand how the characters got together before we can move on to Harry and Ron being all domesticky and snuggling in bed on a Sunday afternoon. I think we also have to start with "obvious" plotlines - get used to them, answer all of those "OMG WHAT HAPPENS NEXT" questions for ourselves until we are satisfied - before we can move on and explore the rest.
So, when
you first enter a new fandom, what is your writing/reading pattern? Do you feel the same way, or have you experienced it differently? Also, do you think new people should read some of the fandom classics before they start writing, or is the catharsis just as important?
Something else I've been thinking about, whilst snooping about for Prince of Tennis recs and spying on some discussions, is how much the quality and scope of fic evolves over time. When fandoms are young and naive, I think everybody is exploring the canon together and building off of one another's ideas. As the fandom as a whole matures, I think the fics do too. I think a lot of fics are written as reactions to what's already been done, when someone thinks, "Oh, that's interesting, but maybe if I flipped it around...or took it a step further and did
this..."
Thinking about all this has made me understand why influxes of new people into a fandom can lead to wank and people splitting into factions. New people feel like they aren't being taken seriously because they "don't understand" and older people feeling frustrated that their groundwork is being overlooked and that new people feel like they have to reinvent the wheel every time. I empathize with both sides and I think it's kind of an unavoidable situation, unfortunately.
There was more that I was thinking about, but now I've forgotten it. But I think the the basic point is that if you want to write me a fic where Harry and Ron get drunk and have sex for the first time and then wake up and worry that the other person doesn't feel the same way and then make Hermione push them back together because she knows everything, THEN DO IT. There is no such thing as too much boysex.
ETA: I am done editing this post now, sorry. :| Why do I always think of more stuff to say the second I hit "post"?